Home Cyber Attack Cloning U2F Hardware Security Keys Possible With Certain Attack Limitations

Cloning U2F Hardware Security Keys Possible With Certain Attack Limitations

by Abeerah Hashim

Hardware security keys are among the most robust account security tools of today. However, researchers have found how to clone these hardware security keys, thus risking the account security. Nonetheless, the overall attack has numerous limitations which still make using U2F security keys a better choice.

Clone Hardware Security Keys

Researchers from NinjaLab have found a way to clone hardware security keys threatening U2F security. As disclosed via their post, a side-channel attack can possibly allow an adversary to target the secure element in U2F-based hardware security keys and extract the encryption key.

Targeting the secure chip this way allows the attacker to make a clone of the security key. In turn, it lets the adversary break into the victims’ accounts.

Briefly, in their study, the researchers aimed at the Google Titan Security Key, targeting its NXP A700X chip. The chip basically implements ECDSA signatures as the core cryptography. Whereas, exploiting the electromagnetic radiations of the chip during the cryptographic process could possibly allow recovering the private key.

To understand the ECDSA engine, they took the help of Rhea (NXP J3D081 JavaCard smartcard) that implements the same cryptographic library.

Eventually, they could recover the private key from Rhea, and in turn, from Google Titan keys as well.

The vulnerability has received the identifier CVE-2021-3011. Whereas, regarding the vulnerable products, this attack affects many hardware security keys, which predominantly include the Google Titan Security Keys. Precisely, the list of vulnerable products includes the following,

  • Google Titan Security Key (all versions)
  • Yubico Yubikey Neo
  • Feitian FIDO NFC USB-A / K9
  • Feitian MultiPass FIDO / K13
  • Feitian ePass FIDO USB-C / K21
  • Feitian FIDO NFC USB-C / K40
  • NXP J3D081_M59_DF and variants
  • NXP J3A081 and variants
  • NXP J2E081_M64 and variants
  • NXP J3D145_M59 and variants
  • NXP J3D081_M59 and variants
  • NXP J3E145_M64 and variants
  • NXP J3E081_M64_DF and variants

Attack Limitations Make It Less Likely

While the attack sounds almost perfect to extract private keys and ruin the security of U2F authentication, it isn’t feasible for real-time attacks due to several limitations.

The main limitation here is that the attacker should have explicit and prolonged physical access to the target security key to clone it.

Besides, the overall experimental setup is quite expensive to afford for an average attacker.

Nonetheless, for the most determined adversaries, executing such attacks isn’t entirely impossible.

Therefore, the researchers advise the users to switch to the more secure hardware security keys.

However, they still recommend using these security keys (including Google Titan) to protect accounts instead of not using any.

The researchers have presented their findings in detail in their report here.

You may also like

Leave a Comment

Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!

Privacy Preference Center

Necessary

The __cfduid cookie is used to identify individual clients behind a shared IP address and apply security settings on a per-client basis.

cookie_notice_accepted and gdpr[allowed_cookies] are used to identify the choices made from the user regarding cookie consent.

For example, if a visitor is in a coffee shop where there may be several infected machines, but the specific visitor's machine is trusted (for example, because they completed a challenge within your Challenge Passage period), the cookie allows Cloudflare to identify that client and not challenge them again. It does not correspond to any user ID in your web application, and does not store any personally identifiable information.

__cfduid, cookie_notice_accepted, gdpr[allowed_cookies]

Advertising

DoubleClick by Google refers to the DoubleClick Digital Marketing platform which is a separate division within Google. This is Google’s most advanced advertising tools set, which includes five interconnected platform components.

DoubleClick Campaign Manager: the ad-serving platform, called an Ad Server, that delivers ads to your customers and measures all online advertising, even across screens and channels.

DoubleClick Bid Manager – the programmatic bidding platform for bidding on high-quality ad inventory from more than 47 ad marketplaces including Google Display Network.

DoubleClick Ad Exchange: the world’s largest ad marketplace for purchasing display, video, mobile, Search and even Facebook inventory.

DoubleClick Search: is more powerful than AdWords and used for purchasing search ads across Google, Yahoo, and Bing.

DoubleClick Creative Solutions: for designing, delivering and measuring rich media (video) ads, interactive and expandable ads.

doubleclick

Analytics

The _ga is asssociated with Google Universal Analytics - which is a significant update to Google's more commonly used analytics service. This cookie is used to distinguish unique users by assigning a randomly generated number as a client identifier. It is included in each page request in a site and used to calculate visitor, session and campaign data for the sites analytics reports. By default it is set to expire after 2 years, although this is customisable by website owners.

The _gat global object is used to create and retrieve tracker objects, from which all other methods are invoked. Therefore the methods in this list should be run only off a tracker object created using the _gat global variable. All other methods should be called using the _gaq global object for asynchronous tracking.

_gid works as a user navigates between web pages, they can use the gtag.js tagging library to record information about the page the user has seen (for example, the page's URL) in Google Analytics. The gtag.js tagging library uses HTTP Cookies to "remember" the user's previous interactions with the web pages.

_ga, _gat, _gid